Thursday 18 April 2013

Mechanical Man


Time was when economies flourished, business was booming and Leaders of Business didn’t have to worry about messy things that they didn’t understand, like people and all their irrationalities.  The rational world of behaviourism worked wonderfully well on the basis of what you put in predicts what you get out.  Of course it did.  Bonuses were dangled and people performed.
Then things started to get a bit shaky.  Heads were scratched.  The Leaders of Business kind of knew they were missing something but they didn’t want to admit it nor get their hands dirty.  But the day was saved by the heroic likes of Messrs Ariely, Kahneman and Thaler.  It was a little bit messy they told us, but not to worry because they had it all worked out so that although it wasn’t as simple as it was before, here are all the rules that you need to know.  Basically you can still have a system that predicts what you get out based on what you put in.  And in a stroke of marketing brilliance they called it Behavioural Economics, using two favourite words in one neat phrase.  No wonder the Leaders of Business loved it.  They could now go about their business with the confidence that they Understand People.
But the real understanding remains untouched by the Leaders of Business, who have MBA’s and who ‘invest in people’.  If they did they would understand and deal with the culture that exists in most organizations where employees have to succeed, so cannot take risks, who have to know, so cannot learn, who have to perform so cannot try a new way.  They would understand the excruciating anxiety that this culture induces and the inhibition of creativity and potential that results.  They would take steps to model a new way of being that celebrates trying with its associated failures, that supports not knowing and learning, that accepts flaws in the face of the impossibility of perfection.  Even in themselves. 
And then, maybe, the Leaders in Business could start to open up to understanding the real messy world of people with their anxieties and defenses, emotions, hopes and irrationalities that exist beyond the doors of their corporate headquarters and the sanitized world of Behavioural Economics.